Citizens Tool Kit Black Box Voting - America's Elections Watchdog Group blackboxvoting.org - caught on videotape
blackboxvoting.org - New Today!
SHORTCUTS: How to find what you're looking for
your donations are always needed and very much appreciated Visa - Mastercard - AMEX blackboxvoting.org - news blackboxvoting.org - investigations blackboxvoting.org Press Kit blackboxvoting.org forums blackboxvoting.org - contact us blackboxvoting.org - home
Navigation
  Topics
  Log In
  Log Out
:
Special Search
  New Today
  New This Week
  Advanced Search
  Tree View

Your Account
  Edit Profile
  Register
  Forgot Password

Tools
  Help/Instructions
  Policies


  ...

Rate Post  
 

Keep this post in Best of Black Box?

    No    Yes

Author Message
Top of pagePrevious messageNext messageBottom of page Link to this message

Sharon M. Foster
Frequent Voting Rights Forum Participant
Username: Smfoster

Post Number: 108
Registered: 02-2006

Best of Black Box? N/A
Votes: 0

Posted on Saturday, October 27, 2007 - 5:27 am:   

Well said, Marian! The interfaces between systems, and the fact that more than one subsystem may be involved in any e-voting scheme, is not a topic that has been discussed much in this forum recently. The fact that changing one variable, or one field, can impact another subsystem is not a mystery to people who develop mission- or safety-critical software. For one thing, in those environments you can't change a single line of code without jumping through a whole lot of hoops. For another thing, the interfaces between subsystems are very well-defined. Several layers of review and then testing catch most (but not all!) errors of this kind. Unfortunately sometimes the customer ends up being the beta tester, which is what happened here.

But that's only the error that got caught. What about the errors that didn't get caught, even in beta test?
 

The public must be able to see and authenticate these four essential steps for an election to be public, democratic, and valid: (1) Who can vote (voter list); (2) Who did vote (3) The original count; (4) Chain of custody.